Search
Industry Updates

Evergreen Funds and Principal and Agency Cross-Trades

Evergreen funds, which are so popular with retail investors, need a robust valuation policy addressing principal and agency cross-trades.

Related Services

Evergreen funds have seen dynamic growth in recent years, against the backdrop of a structural shift in demand for private assets from retail investors.

Allocations to private markets have increased dramatically from individual and wealth management channels, bringing both enhanced yields and diversification away from public markets, which have traditionally been the preserve of institutional investors.

Through the use of evergreen wrappers, which remove key barriers for participation by retail investors, the asset management industry has unlocked a growing source of new capital. The removal of capital calls and unpredictable distributions, along with lower investment minimums, have made evergreen funds a highly attractive product for financial advisers to recommend to their clients, widening the investor base.

Evergreen funds provide an open-ended structure, with continuous subscriptions and redemptions. Moving away from the closed-ended limited life nature of traditional private credit, private equity, and real asset funds, evergreen funds are established with a flexible perpetual capital structure, with a published periodic NAV and liquidity cycle.  As these funds are always in the market, continuously recycling capital, they are more efficient for investors, eliminating the cash drag from distributions typically associated with closed-ended funds.

The expansion of global distribution platforms and regulatory innovation, has provided a platform for this growth, driving adoption of evergreen fund wrappers across the US, UK, and EU.

Furthermore, converging demand for secondaries and evergreen funds has propelled the use of continuation vehicles, which serve as a source of mature assets for some evergreen funds. Synergies in this area mean that evergreen funds can gain access to de-risked, cash flow positive assets early in their lifecycle. With the combination of increased demand and the popularity of open-ended structures, as well as more reliable trading valuations, conditions look conducive for continued strong growth in this product.

Among key operational considerations, evergreen funds offer tradable NAVs at a point in time, so the fund’s valuation at each trading cycle is critical. As such, investment managers need to maintain a robust valuation policy which is regularly reviewed, updated, and agreed with their auditors and governing body. Such valuation policy is particularly important in the context of the rules regarding principal and agency cross-trades.

Principal and Agency-Cross Trades – Evergreen Funds

Rule 206(3) of the Advisers Act in the US, provides the rules for principal trades where an adviser or affiliate trades for its own account with a client, such as in this case, with an evergreen fund. It also sets out the rules for agency-cross trades where an adviser (or affiliate), acts for both buyer and seller.

A principal trade occurs when an investment manager trades from its own inventory into a client’s account. Loan originations for private credit followed by a seasoning period serves as one example, as would the transfer of a warehoused asset. An agency-cross trade occurs when an adviser causes one client account to buy an asset from another client account, with the adviser acting as the agent for both parties.

Cross trades within an evergreen fund represent a conflict of interests, because the adviser controls the pricing on both sides and the evergreen fund uses the struck NAV for subscriptions and redemptions. Evergreen structures, therefore, require a more robust and rigid valuation framework than closed-end funds. Where neither the seller or buyer are using the adviser’s inventory, then agency cross-trade rules will apply, for example where an affiliated fund sells a hard-to-value asset into the evergreen structure.

Valuation Considerations

In addition to the requirement for a robust valuation policy, both principal and cross trades require fair and independent pricing provided by a third-party valuation service, an independent pricing service, or observable market quotations. The adviser must demonstrate that the trade is in the best interest of both accounts and that the client is neither advantaged or disadvantaged.

Furthermore, evergreen funds should have appropriate disclosures in the offering documents, fully documenting the valuation policy used to value the portfolio at each NAV and in arriving at pricing for trades between affiliate entities.

Managing Liquidity

Due to their open-ended structure, evergreen funds offer tradable NAVs at a point in time and in some situations will incorporate withdrawal or redemption gates to manage liquidity risk and avoid the potential for forced asset sales. These gates can include limits at the fund or investor level, as well as side-pockets, and suspensions if market and/or liquidity conditions sufficiently deteriorate.

Funds which do not have gate provisions will utilise notice periods and impose redemption fees, while maintaining redemption suspensions if situations reach a point where the fund cannot meet its redemption demands. Funds can also use a first-in, first-redeemed queue where redemptions which are not filled at the next NAV are carried over with priority to the next redemption opening.

If an evergreen fund needs liquidity and another affiliated fund desires the asset, it is not permitted without full cross-trade controls in place under the relevant US legislation, although requirements may differ in other jurisdictions. Where new investors subscribe into the evergreen fund and the adviser shifts assets into the fund from an affiliated fund, the same cross-trade requirements will apply. Any assets transferred between affiliated funds must not distort the NAV to benefit redeeming investors, subscribing investors, the adviser, or another affiliate.

Under Rule 206(3) of the Investment Advisers Act, an investment manager cannot undertake a principal trade with a client unless the adviser discloses that it is acting as principal, prior to trade settlement, and the client consents to the trade. Records must be retained showing disclosure and consent along with price fairness and valuation controls.

Up-front blanket consent is not acceptable under 206(3). Trade-by-trade consent by the investors or an appointed governing body such as an LPAC are operationally heavy, as approval prior to execution is often required. Appointing an independent conflict representative, with the ability to operate at scale, may provide operational and governance benefits  for evergreen funds, eliminating the compliance burden from the adviser, its governing bodies, and the investors.

Conflict Advisory Review Services – Third Party Consent

The Maples Group provides Conflict Advisory Review Services (“CAR Services”) to help clients seeking to manage and resolve conflicts of interest, often arising in the context of trade allocations and transfers between affiliated investment portfolios. Our fiduciary professionals are highly experienced and qualified to independently review proposed trades and, as appropriate, to provide consent. With a large Cayman Islands based team, the Maples Group is well placed and has established processes to ensure that transactions can be reviewed and signed off within agreed timeframes as required to ensure compliance with 206(3) rules and to properly assess any risks relevant to evergreen funds.

If you have any questions regarding CAR Services for principal or agency cross-trades, please reach out to the author or your usual Maples Group contact.

Menu