Bank Liquidation by Legislation
27 Mar 2013
IBRC Act: Purpose
The IBRC Act is designed to help address "the continuing serious disturbance in the economy of the State" and to "protect the interests of taxpayers". It provides for the winding up of IBRC to bring to an end the financial exposure of the State and the Irish Central Bank to IBRC. It is stated that it is hoped that it will "help restore the financial position of the State" and restore confidence in the banking sector by "furthering the reorganisation of the Irish banking system".
The IBRC Act signalled a premature end for IBRC in the form of a novel and untested procedure known as a special liquidation, as opposed to the typical winding up process under the Companies Acts.
The IBRC Act provides for the appointment of one or more special liquidators by the Minister for Finance for the purposes of winding up IBRC. On 7 February 2013, the Minister, under the provisions of the IBRC Act, made a "Special Liquidation Order" (as defined in the IBRC Act) (the "Order") providing for the winding up of IBRC and the appointment of Kieran Wallace and Eamonn Richardson, both of KPMG, as joint Special Liquidators with all of the duties and powers conferred on them by the IBRC Act. The joint Special Liquidators have full custody and power over all IBRC assets.
All borrowers' loans will initially be managed by the joint Special Liquidators and all debts due to IBRC will remain due and enforceable.
Loan Sales to Third Parties
Portfolios of assets including the mortgage book of IBRC will be identified by the joint Special Liquidators who will oversee an independent valuation and sales process of such assets to third party bidders. The bidding process will be conducted in an open and transparent manner. If acceptable bids equal to or in excess of the independent valuation are obtained then they will be sold to third parties. Otherwise, the relevant portfolio will be sold into the National Asset Management Agency ("NAMA") at their valuation price.
The proceeds of these sales will be used to repay creditors in accordance with normal Irish Companies Acts priorities, with preferred creditors paid first, and then NAMA in respect of the IBRC debt. To the extent that there are proceeds available after repayment in full of the NAMA debt, these proceeds will be applied to remaining unsecured creditors who have not been paid under the guarantee schemes (the statutory Deposit Guarantee Scheme which cover retail deposits up to €100,000 with all Irish authorised credit institutions and the Eligible Liabilities Guarantee which applies to deposits over €100,000 with certain credit institutions including IBRC). These remaining unsecured creditors will include the Minister for Finance to the extent that he has paid out under the guarantee schemes. Similarly, if the proceeds are not sufficient to pay IBRC’s debt to NAMA, the shortfall to NAMA will be met by the existing Ministerial guarantee under the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Act 2008. There are also provisions in the IBRC Act enabling the varying of priorities for certain creditors.
Special Liquidation Order: Effect
The Order made by the Minister for Finance provides:
(a) for an immediate stay on all proceedings against IBRC;
(b) that no further actions or proceedings can be issued against IBRC without High Court consent;
(c) that no action or proceedings for the winding up of IBRC, or the appointment of a liquidator or an examiner can be taken, issued, continued or commenced;
(d) for the removal of any liquidator or examiner appointed prior to the Order; and
(e) that it constitutes notice of termination of employment for each employee with immediate effect.
The appointment of a receiver pursuant to a debenture or charge created by IBRC does not constitute proceedings for the purposes of the Order.
The joint Special Liquidators will have the same duties and powers as a normal liquidator except that they are appointed by the Minister for Finance and are obliged to comply with the instructions given to them by the Minister for Finance and act in the interests of the taxpayer.
The Order shall for the purposes of any contract, deed or agreement have the same effect as the making of a winding up by court order or appointment of an official liquidator.
Under the IBRC Act, the application of the Companies Acts to the special liquidation has been limited and certain provisions of the Companies Acts are deemed not to apply. In doing so, the traditional role of the High Court in court liquidations has been abrogated and in the large part replaced by the Minister.
The provision of the IBRC Act imposing an immediate stay on all proceedings against IBRC has been the subject of some controversy and question-marks as to its constitutionality. To put the potential impact of this provision in context, it is reported that cases against IBRC, which are currently before the Commercial division of the Irish High Court, comprise approximately one-third of that court's workload.
Last month, Sean Quinn and his family, who brought actions against IBRC in 2011 alleging that they are not liable for some €2.34 billion of loans granted by Anglo to companies owned by the Quinn family, applied to the Commercial Court requesting that the stay be lifted. In a judgment delivered on 15 March 2013, the court decided that "a fair proper and constitutional interpretation and also a similar approach based on common law" led to "the inevitable conclusion that the stay…was intended to be subject to being lifted on application to this Court".
The special liquidation of IBRC is an entirely unprecedented and novel procedure in Ireland. It would appear that the Minister for Finance retains a considerable degree of control in respect of the special liquidation and it remains to be seen how it will deviate from the normal corporate liquidation process.
The Irish office of Maples and Calder has been advising financial institutions, private equity firms and asset managers on all aspects of Irish distressed real estate loan portfolio sales.
T: +353 1 619 2031
Partner Cayman Islands
T: +1 345 814 5559
Partner Hong Kong
T: +852 3690 7475
T: +353 1 619 2111
Associate Hong Kong
T: +852 3690 7526
Associate Cayman Islands
T: +1 345 814 5534
Of Counsel Cayman Islands
T: +1 345 814 5460
T: +65 6922 8416