Announcements Maples Group Welcomes US Bankruptcy Courts Decision on the Rights of Investors in Cayman Islands Funds

20 Aug 2019

In recognising the Cayman Islands liquidation proceedings of Ascot Fund Ltd ("Fund"), a Cayman Islands incorporated company, the US Bankruptcy Court (the "Bankruptcy Court") held that investors in Cayman Islands funds had a legitimate expectation that their rights are to be determined by Cayman Islands law. 
 
Fund's principal asset was its limited partner interest in a Delaware partnership, Ascot Partners L.P. ("Partners"). Partners invested all of its assets with BLMIS through which Madoff ran his Ponzi scheme. When BLMIS collapsed Partners, directly, and Fund, indirectly, lost their investments. Following distributions from BLMIS and possible future distributions, Partners had a substantial amount of money to distribute to its investors. A New York receiver (the "Receiver") had been appointed over Partners' assets. A shareholder of Fund (the "Shareholder") was concerned that any distribution methodology used by Fund would be less favourable than a New York court may adopt. The Shareholder commenced an action in the New York Supreme Court seeking, among other things, a declaration as to the distribution methodology that Fund should utilise (arguing that the methodology should be New York law based).  The Shareholder was attempting to use New York proceedings to end run around the Cayman Islands liquidation.
 
Finding that Fund's centre of main interests was in the Cayman Islands (as its headquarters and management had at all times been in the Cayman Islands) the US Bankruptcy Court rejected the Shareholder's arguments. The Shareholder should not be able to avoid the effect of a Cayman Islands liquidation by commencing proceedings before the New York court. The Shareholder had invested in a fund incorporated in the Cayman Islands whose articles of association and subscription agreements were governed by Cayman Islands law. Further, each investor agreed to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the Cayman Islands courts in relation to the subscription agreement and disputes in relation thereto. Therefore, while Delaware or New York law would determine how the Receiver would distribute Partner's assets to Fund, Cayman Islands law would determine how Fund's assets would be distributed to its shareholders. This was consistent with Fund's documents and the expectation of its shareholders. These factors militated in favour of the Bankruptcy Court acceding to the request from one of the Cayman Islands liquidators, Michael Penner of Deloitte, that those Cayman liquidation proceedings should be recognised in the US pursuant to chapter 15 of the US Bankruptcy Code. From the perspective of investor certainty in Cayman Islands funds, the approach of the Bankruptcy Court is to be welcomed.
 
The Maples Group team is led by partner James Eldridge and associate Malachi Sweetman, acting as Cayman Islands counsel to the Fund. Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP act as New York counsel for the Fund.
 

CONTACTS

bioImage

James Eldridge

Partner

+1 345 814 5239

bioImage

Malachi Sweetman

Associate

+1 345 814 5233

*
*
*
*

Please note that your email may be received and read by other Maples and Calder lawyers in addition to your intended recipient.

*
*
*

Please note that your email may be received and read by other Maples Group employees in addition to your intended recipient.

Related

Announcements

Maples Group Recognised by Bloomberg for its Expertise in International Tax

Three partners from Maples and Calder, the Maples Group's law firm, have been recognised by Bloomberg Tax & Accounting in their 2019 author awards for international tax.

Read more

18 Nov 2019

Announcements

Maples Group Expands Cayman Fiduciary Services Team

The Maples Group has announced the appointment of a number of strategic hires to its team in the Cayman Islands to provide specialist services to a broad range of structured finance transactions and special purpose vehicles.

Read more

18 Nov 2019

Announcements

Maples Group Maintains Top Tier Global Rankings in IFLR1000 

IFLR1000 has released its 2020 financial and corporate law rankings and Maples and Calder, the Maples Group's law firm, has achieved top tier rankings across its international offices. 

 

Read more

14 Nov 2019

Announcements

The Maples Group Celebrates 2000 Employee Milestone

 The Maples Group marked a very important milestone in its more than 50 year history, having recently welcomed its two thousandth member of staff.

Read more

14 Nov 2019

Announcements

Maples Partner a "Rising Star" at European Legal Awards
 

Euromoney Legal Media Group has recognised Dublin lawyer, Lynn Cramer as a "Rising Star Ireland" at its inaugural European Rising Star awards. 

The awards celebrate rising star lawyers across 20 different practice areas from 19 European countries. A "Rising Star" according to the publication, is defined as a lawyer under the age of 40. 

Read more

13 Nov 2019

Announcements

Maples Group Relocates Two Senior Litigators to London

The Maples Group is pleased to announce the relocation of two of its senior Dispute Resolution and Insolvency lawyers from its British Virgin Islands and Cayman Islands offices to London. 

Read more

05 Nov 2019

Connect

Want to get in touch ?

Contact Us